Generative AI Policy
Scope and General Principle
Indonesian Physical Review (IPR) recognises that generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) tools may be used in scientific research and scholarly writing, but such use must not compromise research integrity, transparency, confidentiality, reproducibility, or human accountability. This policy applies to all authors, reviewers, editors, and editorial staff.
Generative AI includes systems that produce or substantially transform text, code, images, figures, audio, or other content in response to prompts or data inputs. The same ethical obligations apply regardless of the name or commercial provider of the tool.
Authorship and Human Accountability
Generative AI tools cannot qualify as authors and must not be included in the manuscript’s author list or assigned responsibility for scientific findings. Authors must personally verify all claims, references, calculations, code, figures, analyses, and interpretations associated with their submission. Human authors remain fully responsible for errors, plagiarism, fabricated citations, misleading outputs, and breaches of privacy or intellectual property rights, whether or not AI tools were involved.
Permitted and Restricted Uses by Authors
AI-assisted language editing, translation support, brainstorming, and drafting assistance may be used when authors critically assess the output, preserve the originality of their research, and comply with the disclosure requirements below. Use of GenAI for coding, data processing, methodological design, or analytical support is subject to transparent and reproducible documentation when it materially affects the scientific work.
Authors must not use GenAI to invent or manipulate experimental or observational data; fabricate results, references, ethics approvals, reviewer comments, or participant information; conceal plagiarism; or present generated interpretations as verified scientific findings without independent validation. AI-generated illustrations must not be represented as authentic experimental data or photographs. Reuse of copyrighted or sensitive inputs must respect applicable permissions and data protection obligations.
Required Disclosure of Substantive AI Assistance
Authors must disclose substantive use of GenAI that contributes to manuscript content or the research process, including material text generation, methodological planning, code generation, data analysis, interpretation, images, figures, and translation that materially affects scientific meaning. The disclosure should identify the tool or service, describe its role, and explain how the authors verified the output. When relevant to reproducibility, report the model/version, date used, key processing steps, and human validation procedures.
Authors must include a section titled "Declaration of AI Use" in their manuscripts when substantive GenAI assistance has been used. For AI-assisted research methods, data analysis, or code development, relevant technical details must also be described in the Methods section to support transparency and reproducibility. Routine spelling, punctuation, and minor language corrections that do not materially alter scientific content generally do not require a separate disclosure. The editor may request further clarification when necessary.
Example disclosure — language support
“During manuscript preparation, the authors used [tool and version] to assist with language editing of author-written text. All revisions were reviewed and verified by the authors, who take full responsibility for the final content.”
Example disclosure — code or analysis assistance
“The authors used [tool and version] to assist with drafting analysis code for [specific task]. The code was independently tested against [validation method], and all results and interpretations were checked by the authors. The underlying data and validated code are available as described in the Data Availability Statement.”
AI-Generated Images, Figures, and Research Data
AI-generated images or illustrative elements must be clearly identified when submitted and must satisfy scientific relevance, originality, and any applicable copyright or privacy requirements. The journal may decline an AI-generated image if the origin, transformation, or authenticity cannot be adequately established.
Scientific images and primary research data must not be generated, reconstructed, or altered in a way that falsely implies empirical observation. Where computationally generated data, simulations, or synthetic datasets are a legitimate component of research, the methods must be explicitly described, justified, and reproducible; they must not be misrepresented as observations.
Computational simulations, numerical visualisations, and synthetic datasets used for legitimate scientific purposes are permitted, provided that their generation methods, assumptions, and validation procedures are clearly documented.
AI Use by Reviewers
Reviewers must treat manuscripts, supporting data, correspondence, and review reports as confidential. Reviewers must not upload unpublished manuscript content, identifiable reviewer or author information, or confidential review correspondence to publicly accessible GenAI services or other systems without explicit journal authorisation and appropriate safeguards.
Peer-review evaluations must reflect the reviewer’s own expertise and independent judgment. Reviewers must not delegate the substance of peer review to AI. Any authorised use of AI that materially assists preparation of the review must be disclosed to the handling editor. Reviewers remain responsible for the accuracy, fairness, confidentiality, and originality of their reports.
AI Use by Editors and Editorial Staff
Editors and journal staff must not delegate manuscript acceptance, rejection, reviewer selection, or the determination of scientific merit to generative AI systems. The use of tools for administrative support must comply with confidentiality, privacy, security, and editorial independence requirements.
Unpublished manuscripts and confidential editorial materials must not be entered into general-purpose GenAI services unless the journal has explicitly approved a secure workflow with appropriate protections. Any potential conflict of interest or suspected misuse should be referred to the Editor-in-Chief or an independent editor.
Verification, Non-Disclosure, and Breaches
The journal may request clarification of AI-assisted activities, disclosure statements, source data, code, prompts or workflow summaries when these are necessary to assess reproducibility or investigate integrity concerns and can be supplied without exposing protected information. The use of automated AI-content detectors, if any, does not by itself establish misconduct.
Failure to disclose material AI assistance, fabrication of AI-related information, misuse of confidential information, or reliance on unverified generated content may lead to requests for revision, rejection, correction, expression of concern, or retraction, depending on the evidence and the seriousness of the issue. The journal will apply its Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement and relevant COPE guidance when handling allegations.
Relationship to Other Journal Policies
This policy forms an integral part of IPR's Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement and should be read together with the Peer Review Process, Author Guidelines, Copyright Notice, and Data Availability Policy. All policies are intended to uphold consistent standards of research integrity, transparency, accountability, and responsible scholarly publishing.
This policy applies to manuscripts submitted on or after its effective date. Allegations concerning previously published articles will be assessed in accordance with the ethical standards and policies applicable to those publications, together with relevant research integrity principles and COPE guidance.

